About my collection
Idiosyncratic Notes on Science Fiction and Fantasy
Tom Evans (the idiot responsible)
How did this project get started?
I got tired of looking up my reviews on Goodreads, and I knew I had a box of 3-by-5 cards with notes from the late 1960s and early 1970s. So, the annotations are memory joggers for my octogenarian brain based on my Goodreads reviews and notes from the Nixon era.
I now have more than 4,000 titles by 1,200 writers. Will it ever be done? Only when I am.
The length or absence of an annotation is not a measure of the book’s quality.
I hope that inconsistency is the soul of genius. I haven’t read dead-tree books for years, but I don’t always specify e-book editions. Nor do I often indicate the page numbers for short stories. I figure everyone knows that Kindle books are e-books and that if a book has a narrator, it’s an audiobook. I pretend artificial voices don’t exist, even though I listen to them all the time.
My grammar nanny complains that “old man” isn't PC, but since I am one, I use it anyway.
I have begun dating annotations, so if you are looking for the new stuff, search for “2026.”
I have also begun adding biographical information about the authors based on a quick Web search. The effort has given me a new pet peeve: author bio pages with no information. I know they are sales documents and not full CVs, but still.
Please let me know where my shortcomings made you wince and what I can do to make this thing more useful.
Tread carefully if you are allergic to spoilers.
Finally, here is an idiosyncratic list of some of my favorites with a hint at what I liked about them.
— Tom
About this edition
These pages preserve my notes, citations, and thumbnail biographies. Biographical details and opinions reflect my source document.
- Document’s update line
- 30 October 2026
- Word file last saved
- 5 November 2026
- In this edition
- 1,249 authors; 4,090 works
Some of my citations are incomplete or inconsistent. The length or absence of an annotation is not a measure of a book’s quality.