Decision at Doona
Ballantine, 1969.
When I read it in 1972, I liked the aliens, but not the science or the preaching.
11 works in my collection.
McCaffrey (1926-2011) gave us human brains uploaded into spacecraft. She was also one of many writers to discover the tax benefits of moving to Ireland.
A note on spoilers. I discuss plots and endings in my notes. Tread carefully if you are allergic to spoilers.
Ballantine, 1969.
When I read it in 1972, I liked the aliens, but not the science or the preaching.
1968. E-book, Del Rey, 2002.
A fix-up novel that takes standard fantasy tropes and gives them far-fetched scientific explanations. 3.5 stars. (7 September 20276)
Analog, December 1967.
Nebula winner. This novella and its sequel would become the core of Dragonflight.
1998. Del Rey 2000.
Series: Crystal Singers Universe · 0.4
Listed without an annotation.
1996. Leisure Books, 2007.
When Prince Jamas comes of age, his wise old regent dies and is immediately reincarnated as a cat named Niffy. Without language, the cat continues to offer advice, which Jamas is wise enough to take. I wonder if this inspired the cats in Starter Villain.
Ballantine, 1967.
McCaffrey’s first novel. An alien abduction adventure. I thought it showed promise.
Far Horizons, edited by Robert Silverberg. E-book, HarperCollins, 1999, pp. 455-501.
Compared to the other stories in the anthology, this Brainship story is a tired, phone-it-in affair. Helva talks with the hologram of her dead brawn. There is something about pirates and nuns who don’t need to be rescued. They are just pieces of business thrown together. (February 2026)
1973. Del Rey, 2002.
Series: Talent · 1
A fix-up in which Pegasus is a metaphor for a powerful Psi talent that is hard to live with.
Worlds of If, December 1973.
Listed without an annotation.
and Elizabeth Moon
Baen, 1990.
Series: Planet Pirates · 1
A hard-edged story of young Sassinak’s enslavement by planet pirates and her rescue. After becoming a Fleet officer, she rescues one of her ancestors who has been in cryosleep for years.
and Margaret Ball
Baen, 1992.
Series: Brainship · 2
Listed without an annotation.